0.03/0.12 % Problem : theBenchmark.p : TPTP v0.0.0. Released v0.0.0. 0.03/0.13 % Command : do_CVC4 %s 0.13/0.34 % Computer : n012.cluster.edu 0.13/0.34 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.13/0.34 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.13/0.34 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.13/0.34 % CPULimit : 180 0.13/0.34 % DateTime : Thu Aug 29 10:05:27 EDT 2019 0.13/0.34 % CPUTime : 0.19/0.47 %----Proving TH0_NAR 0.19/0.47 ------- cvc4-thf casc 27 : /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p at 180... 0.19/0.47 --- Run --uf-ho --ho-elim --no-ho-elim-store-ax --full-saturate-quant at 20... 20.37/20.54 --- Run --uf-ho --ho-elim --full-saturate-quant at 20... 40.40/40.61 --- Run --uf-ho --ho-elim --finite-model-find --uf-ss=no-minimal at 5... 45.47/45.65 --- Run --uf-ho --no-ho-matching --finite-model-find --uf-ss=no-minimal at 5... 48.44/48.62 % SZS status Theorem for theBenchmark 48.44/48.62 % SZS output start Proof for theBenchmark 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_918 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_918 france)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_918 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_1 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1000 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1000 catalunya)) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1024 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 BOUND_VARIABLE_1024)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 BOUND_VARIABLE_1000)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 BOUND_VARIABLE_1024)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ))) )) (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1000 spain)) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1001 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 BOUND_VARIABLE_1001)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 BOUND_VARIABLE_1000)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 BOUND_VARIABLE_1001)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 spain)) ))) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_985 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_985 spain)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_985 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 france)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 catalunya)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_2)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_6 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_896 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 catalunya)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_7 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_2)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_8 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 catalunya)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_2)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 france)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_11 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 france)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_12 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_896 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 spain)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_13 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 spain)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_14 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 paris)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 spain)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_5)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_17 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_4)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_18 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_3)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_19 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 paris)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_20 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_5)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_21 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_4)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 paris)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_23 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_3)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_24 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 paris)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_25 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_26 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_27 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_15)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_28 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_22)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_29 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 france)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_30 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_9)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_31 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_15)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_15)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_33 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_22)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_34 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_934 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_943 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 BOUND_VARIABLE_934)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 catalunya)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_935 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 BOUND_VARIABLE_934)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 france)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_35 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_36 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_37 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_896 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_38 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 catalunya)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_39 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_10)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_40 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_10)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_41 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_10)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_42 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_15)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_43 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_4)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_44 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_5)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_45 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_22)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_46 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_3)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_47 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_896 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 skv_16)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_16)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_49 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 skv_16)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_50 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (skolem (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_16)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_51 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((X reg)) (c X X) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_7 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_8 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((X reg) (Y reg)) (or (not (c X Y)) (c Y X)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( france, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2, skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_8, skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_17, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_19, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_24, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_25, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, france ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48, skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_49, skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_895 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 BOUND_VARIABLE_895)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_896 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 BOUND_VARIABLE_895)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_896 france)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_926 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_926 paris)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_926 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_7 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_23 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_26 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_933 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_933 paris)) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_933)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) )) (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_933 france)) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_934 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_943 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 BOUND_VARIABLE_934)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 BOUND_VARIABLE_933)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_935 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 BOUND_VARIABLE_934)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 france)) ))) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_993 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_993 catalunya)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_993 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1024 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 BOUND_VARIABLE_1024)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 BOUND_VARIABLE_1024)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1025 catalunya)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1001 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 BOUND_VARIABLE_1001)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1010 skv_2)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 BOUND_VARIABLE_1001)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1002 spain)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_2 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 catalunya)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_957 reg)) (or (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_2)) )) (not (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 BOUND_VARIABLE_957)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ))) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 france)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( france ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( paris ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_26 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_10)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_10)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 paris)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_1033 skv_2)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_16)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_16)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_20)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_9 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_904 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 skv_9)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_904 spain)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_30)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_30)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_31)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_9)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_31)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_32)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_15)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_32)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_943 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 skv_35)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_943 catalunya)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_50 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_935 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 skv_35)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_935 france)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_42)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_10)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( spain ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_42)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_16 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_966 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_51)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_966 skv_16)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( catalunya ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_10 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_15 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 (instantiation (forall ((BOUND_VARIABLE_958 reg)) (or (not (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 skv_51)) (c BOUND_VARIABLE_958 paris)) ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_3 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_4 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_5 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_22 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_32 ) 48.44/48.62 ( skv_48 ) 48.44/48.62 ) 48.44/48.62 % SZS output end Proof for theBenchmark 48.44/48.62 EOF